Scalar Alternatives and Scalar Inference Involving Adjectives: A Comment on van Tiel, et al.(2016)
關鍵詞：scalar implicature adjectives inference alternatives
摘要：Doran, et al.(2009, 2012) and van Tiel, et al.(2016) have presented experimental evidence that gradable adjectives (e.g.cool) yield scalar inferences (e.g.to not cold) significantly less often than do numerals, quantifiers and modals;their data also reveal considerable variability within the class of adjectives in the frequency with which inferences are likely to be generated.Van Tiel, et al.consider two main explanations for this variation:differences among pairs of adjectives in what they call scale distinctness (how easy or difficult it is to differentiate the adjectives), and differences in scale availability (how salient the stronger scalar alternative is).They argue that only scale distinctness plays a role, and a rather small one at that;they leave most of the variation unexplained.In this comment, I argue that their measures of scale availability were too crude to detect a role for contextual variation in the scalar alternatives that subjects consider, but that this latter variation is, in fact, a very plausible part of the explanation for the results.I discuss some specific ways adjectives might yield different scalar alternatives in different contexts, under sufficiently sophisticated assumptions about their lexical semantics and about the rhetorical structure of discourse.
外國語雜志要求:
{1}文稿結構一般為題目、作者姓名、單位、摘要、關鍵詞（僅限技術天地欄目）、引言、正文、參考文獻、基金項目等。
{2}來稿應符合保密規定，文責自負，請勿一稿兩投或多投。
{3}題名須簡明確切地反映本文的特定內容，不要副標題，一般不超過20 字。避免使用非公知公認的縮略詞、字符、代號等。
{4}著錄的參考文獻應準確無誤，其內容及順序是：專著——序號、著（譯）者、書名、卷次、出版社、出版年；期刊一一序號、作者、篇名、刊名、年份、卷期；報紙——序號、作者、篇名、報紙名、年月日、版頁。
{5}“關鍵詞”一般以3至5個為宜。
注：因版權方要求，不能公開全文，如需全文，請咨詢雜志社
